Are gender-critical beliefs classed as 'philosophical beliefs' in equality law? - Paul Doran Law

Belfast Office
12 Carnmoney Road
Glengormley
County Antrim BT36 6HN

Leeds Office
West One
114 Wellington Street
Leeds
West Yorkshire
LS1 1BA

London Office
124 City Road
London EC1V 2NX

Newcastle Office
Gear House
Saltmeadows Road
Gateshead
Tyne and Wear NE8 3AH

Telephone: 0808 1687 288
Email: enquiries@pauldoranlaw.com

Are gender-critical beliefs classed as ‘philosophical beliefs’ in equality law?

Are gender critical beliefs protected as philosophical beliefs.jpgAre gender-critical beliefs classed as ‘philosophical beliefs’ in equality law?

You’ve no doubt noticed that gender is a hot topic at the moment. Transgender stories seemingly appear in the media every day. You might also know there’s a famous employment law case which has recently shed light on the answer to the question in the headline. There’s more on that below, as well as another real-life example.

Protected characteristics

In law, precise definitions of terms make all the difference, and certain characteristics are defined as protected under the Equality Act 2010. These include:

You might agree that most of the protected characteristics are things an individual can’t change, while some of them are in more of a ‘grey area’ (we use that term ironically, especially considering the rainbow flag!)

This article explores some of the issues more deeply.

Philosophical beliefs in law

First, let’s look at what makes a philosophical belief in law.

Since the 2009 case of Grainger plc and others v Nicholson (in which it was decided that a belief in man-made climate change counts as a philosophical belief), the Employment Appeal Tribunal has identified key criteria which need to be satisfied to make a belief protected in law.

What about gender-critical beliefs?

Case study 1

It’s complicated, as shown by the case of Forstater v CGD Europe and others.

Maya Forstater is a consultant, researcher, writer and adviser on sustainable development. From November 2016, she worked at CGD Europe, a not-for-profit think tank focused on international development.

She holds the belief that there are only two sexes, male and female, and that it’s not possible to change from one to the other even if a Gender Recognition Certificate is obtained, and she would share those views publicly. For example, on Twitter, she would refer to a person by the sex she considered appropriate even if the person concerned felt that to do so violated their dignity.

A number of her colleagues alleged that some of Maya’s tweets were “transphobic”, “exclusionary or offensive” and made them feel “uncomfortable”.

As a result, in October 2018, her contract was not renewed.

So, in 2019, she went to the Employment Tribunal alleging direct discrimination and harassment and arguing that her gender-critical opinions amounted to a philosophical belief.

The Employment Tribunal that first heard the case found her views were incompatible with human dignity and not worthy of respect in a democratic society (you’ll notice this goes back to the criteria listed above).

In 2021, she took her case to the Employment Appeal Tribunal which overturned this decision. The EAT said that the only beliefs not worthy of respect in a democratic society would be more extreme, such as those advocating Nazism or Totalitarianism and the gravest forms of inciting hatred and violence.

Even though Maya’s beliefs might be offensive, shocking or disturbing to some, the EAT determined that her views, which it found were were widely shared, and which did not seek to destroy the rights of trans persons, did not fall into that category. Her gender-critical beliefs were therefore found to be protected under the Equality Act (this is also in line with previous case law).

The EAT stressed that the judgement doesn’t mean that anyone with gender-critical beliefs can misgender trans-people with impunity. Employees must not deliberately upset or incite other employees. They also said their ruling was not about taking ‘sides’ with regard to transgender people, but as a point of law – that is, the exact meaning of the criteria.

Case study 2

A similar situation arose in the case of Mackereth v The Department of Work and Pensions and Advanced Personnel Management Group UK Ltd.

Dr David Mackereth was a Health and Disabilities Assessor. As a Christian, he believes in the truth of the Bible, and has a lack of belief in, and conscientious objection to, transgenderism.

As a result of his beliefs, he said he couldn’t in good conscience use the pronoun of a person’s choice, as the DWP required, when referring individuals who were contemplating, undergoing or had undergone gender reassignment.

David alleged he had been discriminated against on the grounds of his religious beliefs. The Employment Tribunal found that his beliefs were incompatible with human dignity and conflicted with the fundamental rights of others and were therefore not worthy of protection.

On appeal, the decision was that he had not been discriminated against but his lack of belief in transgenderism was a belief worthy of protection under the Equality Act 2010.

What this means to you

The European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) includes Article 9 (freedom of thought, conscience and religion) and Article 10 (freedom of expression). So law is also in place to allow people to think and say what they believe.

There’s therefore a fine balance between a person’s right to express philosophical beliefs which you don’t agree with, and your right not to be harassed, victimised or discriminated against because of a protected characteristic that you identify with.

Ideally, your employer should create a culture and environment which tolerates opposing beliefs and encourages freedom of speech while ensuring people with protected characteristics are not harassed or discriminated against.

If you’ve been mistreated or discriminated against at work, let us know. This is one of our main areas of expertise and we’ll be happy to help. The first conversation is free, and with no obligation. So we look forward to speaking to you soon.

Related reading

For more on this subject, please see our related articles:

Need help?

We have already helped thousands of people to win millions of pounds in compensation.

See what they say >

You have a choice of ways to pay, including ‘no win, no fee’.

Browse funding options >

Back to all news

Share Article With:

Call us on
0808 1687288
or fill in this
Free Online Enquiry

(no cost or obligation)

We will only use the information you provide to handle your enquiry, and we will never share it with any third parties.

What Our Clients Say

I found all the staff to be knowledgeable and highly professional. Stephanie W

My experience has been a very professional one. The case ran smoothly from the get go. I was always kept in the loop. Dinah T

Up to date information. Easy to contact. Knowledgeable solicitor. No win without him. Audrey S

Very good. Always stayed within the timescales given. Sound advice, would recommend. Ken S

Efficient and helpful. Takes the claimant points into consideration. Angela R

Paul Doran Law has been extremely helpful and supportive in very difficult circumstances. I would highly recommend them as professionals to others and have a lot of faith in their advice. David R

Although a lengthy case I have been constantly updated throughout. Susan R

Paul answered me promptly, was very helpful and advised me what to do. Winifred P

Paul Doran was very helpful during my communication. Friendly and professional. Adrian M

Cormac is a very reassuring person, he made sure I was kept up to date as my case progressed and was always supportive when I got the jitters. He was very diligent and methodical whilst representing me. Iain M

Professional approach and positive attitude. Shirley M

Competent and efficient and very pleasant to deal with. Cloda McN

Cormac explained my options and talked me through each step and advised me of the best possible outcome. Gerard McL

Very helpful. Emma McA

Satisfied with service. Susan H

Very satisfied with the professional way case was handled. Evelyn H

Staff and solicitor very helpful at all times. Solicitor very knowledgeable and took my case and concerns seriously, and in a very professional manner. Deborah H

Friendly, efficient and very professional. Charlotte G

Very friendly and competent service. Peter G

My experience using Paul was very professional at all times. Kept me up to date at all times throughout the process. Blanche G

Very professional, friendly and efficient. Kept me informed throughout the process. Straight forward service which is exactly what I needed. Paula F

Good end result, Paul did a lot of work. Thank you. Lyn E

Felt at ease and was listened to; got excellent advice. Gemma D

Very professional and always willing to help and offer advice when needed on the situation. Lytreena D

Outstanding, friendly service from start to finish. Matthew C

Very professional and always left valued as a client. I feel that the company has worked very hard to get me a good result. Christine C

From day one there was a plan of action. I feel I was listened to and heard, after which the process was then easy. Kanta C

I would highly recommend. Karen B

Confident in representation. June B

Very happy with all aspects of my experience from initial contact to finish. Andrew B

Understanding and very prompt. Michelle W

Completely professional, and secured a settlement beyond my expectations. Cormac was exceptional – very many thanks. Joan W

Very happy with results. Very grateful for all Paul and his team have done for me. I feel valued as a client, my questions were always answered very quickly. Thank you. Anna V

Very good, professional. Amida S

Always responsive, courteous and supportive. Would recommend to friends and family without hesitation. David S

Easy and efficient and professional at all times. Stephanie R

Very good. Yusuf O

Excellent, efficient and prompt legal advice. Very satisfied with service provided. Lisa N

It took me a long time to find a solicitor who would support my case. I’m so glad I found Paul Doran Law who brought me success. Shirley N

I have had a very pleasant experience using Paul Doran Law and would definitely use again. Rebecca McM

The service was always informative, dignified and respectful. Chloe McL

I would definitely recommend. Colleen McB

Cormac was excellent from start to finish. I have already recommended him to friends and family. Sam M

Paul Doran Law were professional and very concerned about my feelings and what I had been through. I felt that they cared. Lisa M

Professional, helpful, very knowledgeable. Highly recommended. Bekki M

I found Cormac very compassionate and was always there as I had a lot of queries. Stephen McG

Impressed with accessibly, speed of response and professionalism. Edna L

Cormac was very professional and reassuring at all times. Kat K

Great, a good experience. Thank you. Mary K

Professional, efficient and friendly. Tabitha K

Very well treated throughout. I was always listened to and my questions answered. Allan H

I found Mr Rice to be professional, amiable and my overall experience was a positive one. Marcel G

I received valued information initially and came back later to receive a very satisfactory outcome. Lyn F

Put at ease very early on which helped me feel less stress. Harry D

I can’t thank you enough. I am so glad with the outcome and will recommend you. Christopher B

Cormac was great. Tom B

I would recommend Paul’s legal service as it is professional and thorough. Shelia H

This claim has been handled professionally and without delays. I am totally satisfied. Kelly L

Should the need arise I would definitely use Paul Doran’s services again. Suzie U

Any queries were answered quickly with detailed responses.  Sharon H

Everything was written very simply and in plain English which was good. Sylvia B

When time lines have been set, they have been met. I did not just feel like a case number. Karen S

When I emailed, Paul replied straight away.Very friendly and easy to talk to. Rita C

Paul was very thorough and helpful and successfully brought my case to an end. Margaret C

I feel strongly that Paul cares about clients. Pamela R

Paul was very reasonable and fair regarding the fees deducted from my claim offer I was awarded. Deborah McM

Very professional all the way through the process. Sharon C

I found all the staff to be knowledgeable and highly professional. Stephanie W

Well informed and easy to contact. I wouldn’t have won my case without him. Audrey S

Very good. Always stayed within the timescales given. Sound advice. Would recommend. Ken S

Efficient. Helpful. Take the clients points into consideration. Angela R

Paul Doran Law has been extremely helpful and supportive in very difficult circumstances. David R

Although a lengthy case, I have been constantly updated throughout. Jenny R

Professional and efficient service with helpful and friendly staff. Susan R

My case was handled professionally and my solicitor was very understanding and quick to respond. Eleanor P

Paul was very helpful and friendly. Adrian M

Cormac is a very reassuring person. He was very supportive when I got the jitters. Iain M

Kept going when it did not good and achieved a successful outcome. Shirley M

Competent, efficient and very pleasant to deal with. Cloda McN

Cormac deserves a salary for counselling alone! Lesley A

Cormac explained my options and talked me through each step and advised me of the best possible outcome. Gerard McL

They were quick to get things sorted. Emma McA

Very satisfied with the outcome to my case. Evelyn H

Solicitor very knowledgeable and took my case and concerns seriously in a very professional manner. Deborah H

Friendly, efficient and very professional. Charlotte G

I liked the personal touch. I received phone calls with updates instead of relying on letters all of the time. Sharon C

Very friendly and competent service. Peter G

Very professional. Kept me up to date at all times throughout the process. Blanche G

Straightforward service which is exactly what I needed. Paula F

Good end result. Paul did a lot of work. Lyn E

Very professional and always willing to help and offer advice when needed. Lytreena D

Very pleasant manner from staff and solicitors. Sara C

Outstanding. Friendly service from start to finish. Matthew C

I feel the company worked very hard to get the result. Christine C

From day one there was a plan of action. I feel I was listened to and heard after which to prove the case got easy. Kanta C

I would highly recommend. Karen B

Very good overall service. Judith B

Very happy with all aspects of my experience from initial contact to finish. Andrew B

Very professional, friendly and efficient. Kept me informed throughout the process. Paula F

Very professional. I always felt valued as a client Christine C

Paul was extremely professional and efficient Lesley A

Outstanding – friendly service from start to finish Matthew C

Paul Doran was very helpful during my communications, friendly & professional. Adrian M

I found right from the beginning Paul was very friendly and easy to ask questions at any time. Rita C

Paul is prompt, friendly and approachable. I liked how he was committed to my case and kept me informed. Judith P

I appreciate the thorough and expedient manner to which the task was completed. Barbara H

I feel Paul really cares about his clients and works to get the best outcome and justice for them.  Elaine S

My claim has been handled professionaly and without delays.  I am totally satisfied. Kelly L

Paul’s legal service is professional and thorough. Sharon H

I entrusted him with something that was very important to me and he did not let me down. Deborah McM

I was in contact with Paul on many occasions and all queries were dealt with personally and politely. Judith C

It has been a pleasure using Paul Doran Law. I would recommend him to friends and family. Sylvia B

Cormac was an absolute pleasure to work with – very polite, helpful, and thoughtful. Jessica D

Paul was polite and considerate and efficient. I would highly recommend this firm Geraldine A

I have been very impressed by the industry knowledge and the level of service provided. Nuala M

Quick, honest and responsive.

J Chambers

The service provided has been delivered beyond expectation.

K L Stokoe

Recommend without reservation.

J Taylor

If Paul had not taken on my case, I would not have received monies owed to me. E Shefford

I would recommend Paul’s legal service as it is professional and thorough. S Hall

View more testimonials

Why Choose Us?

  • We only work for employees
  • 25+ Years' Experience
  • No Win, No Fee available
  • Insurance to protect against Tribunal fees